| Bottom of 9: |
| Yankees ninth. Chulk pitching. Gardner flied out to left fielder Francisco. Pena flied out to left fielder Francisco. Ransom tripled to right. Matsui walked on four pitches. Molina popped out to second baseman Cabrera. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 1, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 9: |
| Indians ninth. Marte pitching. Garko flied out to right fielder Swisher. Francisco doubled to left. Cabrera singled to left, Francisco to third. Crowe singled to right, Francisco scored, Cabrera to second. DeRosa singled to left, Cabrera to third, Crowe to second. Shoppach struck out. Hafner flied out to left fielder Cabrera. |
| Runs: 1, Hits: 4, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 8: |
| Yankees eighth. Posada flied out to center fielder Crowe. Cano popped out to catcher Shoppach. Cabrera grounded out, pitcher Kobayashi to first baseman Garko. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 8: |
| Indians eighth. Shoppach grounded out, third baseman Ransom to first baseman Posada. Hafner homered to left on a full count. Peralta grounded out, first baseman Posada to pitcher Veras. Choo lined out to third baseman Ransom. |
| Runs: 1, Hits: 1, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 7: |
| Yankees seventh. Shoppach in as catcher. Kobayashi pitching. Matsui was hit by a pitch. Molina grounded into a double play, pitcher Kobayashi to shortstop Peralta to first baseman Garko, Matsui out. Swisher grounded out, first baseman Garko to pitcher Kobayashi. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 7: |
| Indians seventh. Cabrera grounded out, shortstop Pena to first baseman Posada. Crowe grounded out, first baseman Posada to pitcher Veras. DeRosa grounded out, shortstop Pena to first baseman Posada. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 6: |
| Yankees sixth. Swisher grounded out, third baseman DeRosa to first baseman Garko. Posada flied out to left fielder Francisco. Cano singled to left. Cabrera homered to right on a 2-2 count, Cano scored. Gardner walked. Pena singled to center, Gardner to second. Ransom grounded into fielder's choice, third baseman DeRosa to second baseman Cabrera, Pena out. |
| Runs: 2, Hits: 3, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 6: |
| Indians sixth. Matsui in as designated hitter. Molina in as catcher. Posada in as first baseman. Veras pitching. Peralta walked on a full count. Choo struck out. Garko flied out to center fielder Gardner. Francisco struck out. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 5: |
| Yankees fifth. Crowe in as center fielder. Pena lined out to center fielder Crowe. Ransom fouled out to third baseman DeRosa. Matsui pinch-hitting for Damon. Matsui doubled to right. Teixeira grounded out, second baseman Cabrera to first baseman Garko. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 1, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 5: |
| Indians fifth. Garko popped out to right fielder Swisher. Francisco walked on a full count. Cabrera struck out. Sizemore walked, Francisco to second. DeRosa homered to center on a 2-1 count, Francisco scored, Sizemore scored. Martinez homered to right on the first pitch. Hafner struck out. |
| Runs: 4, Hits: 2, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 4: |
| Yankees fourth. Teixeira grounded out, second baseman Cabrera to first baseman Garko. Swisher walked on four pitches. Posada singled to right, Swisher to second. On Choo's error, Swisher to third. Cano grounded out, pitcher Carmona to first baseman Garko, Posada to second. Cabrera walked on a full count. Gardner grounded out, pitcher Carmona to first baseman Garko. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 1, 1 Errors on Cle |
| Top of 4: |
| Indians fourth. Ransom in as third baseman. Pena in as shortstop. Cabrera singled to left. Sizemore doubled to left, Cabrera to third. Ramirez pitching. DeRosa singled to left, Cabrera scored, Sizemore to third. Martinez walked, DeRosa to second. Hafner struck out. Peralta popped out to second baseman Cano. Choo struck out. |
| Runs: 1, Hits: 3, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 3: |
| Yankees third. Pena grounded out, shortstop Peralta to first baseman Garko. Jeter grounded out, third baseman DeRosa to first baseman Garko. Damon struck out. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 3: |
| Indians third. Martinez flied out to center fielder Gardner. Hafner flied out to center fielder Gardner. Peralta singled to left. On Anthony Claggett's wild pitch, Peralta to second. Choo walked. Garko singled to right, Peralta scored, Choo to second. On Swisher's error, Choo to third. Francisco grounded into fielder's choice, third baseman Pena to second baseman Cano, Garko out. |
| Runs: 1, Hits: 2, 1 Errors on NYY |
| Bottom of 2: |
| Yankees second. Cano grounded out, catcher Martinez to first baseman Garko. Cabrera lined out to shortstop Peralta. Gardner flied out to left fielder Francisco. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 2: |
| Indians second. Hafner infield single to third. Peralta singled to left, Hafner to second. Choo homered to left on a 3-1 count, Hafner scored, Peralta scored. Garko fouled out to catcher Posada. Francisco doubled to left. Cabrera singled to center, Francisco scored. Sizemore doubled to right, Cabrera to third. DeRosa doubled to right, Cabrera scored, Sizemore scored. On Wang's wild pitch, DeRosa to third. Martinez singled to right, DeRosa scored. Anthony Claggett pitching. Hafner doubled to left, Martinez to third. Peralta doubled to center, Martinez scored, Hafner scored. Choo walked. Garko singled to center, Peralta to third, Choo to second. Francisco struck out. Cabrera homered to right on a 3-1 count, Peralta scored, Choo scored, Garko scored. Sizemore homered to right on a 2-2 count. DeRosa struck out. |
| Runs: 14, Hits: 13, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 1: |
| Yankees first. Jeter grounded out, second baseman Cabrera to first baseman Garko. Damon walked. Teixeira homered to right on a 1-1 count, Damon scored. Swisher grounded out, second baseman Cabrera to first baseman Garko. Posada flied out to center fielder Sizemore. |
| Runs: 2, Hits: 1, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 1: |
| Indians first. Sizemore struck out. DeRosa popped out to second baseman Cano. Martinez flied out to left fielder Cabrera. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
