| Bottom of 9: |
| Indians ninth. Pena in as third baseman. Berroa in as designated hitter. Veras pitching. Choo homered to center on the first pitch. DeRosa was hit by a pitch. Garko grounded out, first baseman Teixeira unassisted, DeRosa to second. Francisco doubled to left, DeRosa scored. Carroll struck out. Cabrera grounded out, shortstop Jeter to first baseman Teixeira. |
| Runs: 2, Hits: 2, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 9: |
| Yankees ninth. Teixeira doubled to left. A.Rodriguez flied out to center fielder Francisco. Cano singled to right, Teixeira scored. Cano to second. Posada grounded out, first baseman Garko to pitcher Ohka, Cano to third. Matsui doubled to left, Cano scored. Berroa pinch-running for Matsui. Swisher struck out. |
| Runs: 2, Hits: 3, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 8: |
| Indians eighth. Robertson pitching. Sizemore struck out. Shoppach grounded out, third baseman A.Rodriguez to first baseman Teixeira. Peralta grounded out, third baseman A.Rodriguez to first baseman Teixeira. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 8: |
| Yankees eighth. Gardner struck out. Jeter struck out. Damon grounded out, third baseman Peralta to first baseman Garko. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 7: |
| Indians seventh. DeRosa grounded out, third baseman A.Rodriguez to first baseman Teixeira. Garko was hit by a pitch. On Sabathia's wild pitch, Garko to second. Francisco lined out to left fielder Damon. Carroll walked on a full count. Cabrera struck out. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 7: |
| Yankees seventh. Cano flied out to center fielder Francisco. Posada popped out to shortstop Cabrera. Matsui singled to left. Swisher grounded out, first baseman Garko unassisted. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 1, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 6: |
| Indians sixth. Sizemore homered to center on a 3-1 count. Shoppach struck out. Peralta walked on a full count. Choo grounded into a double play, second baseman Cano to shortstop Jeter to first baseman Teixeira, Peralta out. |
| Runs: 1, Hits: 1, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 6: |
| Yankees sixth. Gardner walked. Jeter singled to center, Gardner to third. Damon grounded out, first baseman Garko unassisted, Gardner scored, Jeter to second. Teixeira grounded out, first baseman Garko to pitcher Ohka, Jeter to third. A.Rodriguez flied out to center fielder Francisco. |
| Runs: 1, Hits: 1, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 5: |
| Indians fifth. Peralta struck out. Choo infield single to second. DeRosa infield single to first, Choo to third. Garko singled to center, Choo scored, DeRosa to second. Francisco lined out to left fielder Damon. Carroll singled to center, DeRosa scored, Garko to second. Cabrera struck out. |
| Runs: 2, Hits: 4, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 5: |
| Yankees fifth. Ohka pitching. Posada grounded out, first baseman Garko unassisted. Matsui grounded out, second baseman Carroll to first baseman Garko. Swisher grounded out, first baseman Garko to pitcher Ohka. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 4: |
| Indians fourth. Cabrera struck out. Sizemore popped out to shortstop Jeter. Shoppach struck out. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 4: |
| Yankees fourth. Posada grounded out, second baseman Carroll to first baseman Garko. Matsui doubled to center. Swisher walked. Gardner safe on fielder's choice and Garko's error, Matsui to third, Swisher to second. Jeter singled to center, Matsui scored, Swisher scored, Gardner to third. Damon singled to right, Gardner scored, Jeter to second. On Choo's error, Jeter to third. Teixeira grounded into fielder's choice, first baseman Garko to third baseman Peralta to catcher Shoppach, Jeter out, Damon to third. A.Rodriguez walked. Cano singled to center, Damon scored, Teixeira scored, A.Rodriguez to second. A.Rodriguez was out advancing, center fielder Francisco to third baseman Peralta, A.Rodriguez out. |
| Runs: 5, Hits: 4, 2 Errors on Cle |
| Bottom of 3: |
| Indians third. Garko struck out. Francisco flied out to center fielder Gardner. Carroll flied out to right fielder Swisher. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 3: |
| Yankees third. Damon grounded out, second baseman Carroll to first baseman Garko. Teixeira flied out to center fielder Francisco. A.Rodriguez walked. Cano grounded out, third baseman Peralta to first baseman Garko. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 2: |
| Indians second. Peralta flied out to left fielder Damon. Choo walked on a full count. DeRosa grounded into a double play, third baseman A.Rodriguez to second baseman Cano to first baseman Teixeira, Choo out. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 2: |
| Yankees second. Shoppach in as catcher. Posada homered to right on a 2-1 count. Matsui grounded out, second baseman Carroll to first baseman Garko. Swisher homered to center on a 1-1 count. Gardner grounded out, first baseman Garko to pitcher Carmona. Jeter struck out. |
| Runs: 2, Hits: 2, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 1: |
| Indians first. Cabrera grounded out, shortstop Jeter to first baseman Teixeira. Sizemore struck out. Martinez grounded out, second baseman Cano to first baseman Teixeira. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 1: |
| Yankees first. Jeter grounded out, pitcher Carmona to first baseman Garko. Damon grounded out, second baseman Carroll to first baseman Garko. Teixeira singled to right. A.Rodriguez singled to left, Teixeira to second. Cano struck out. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 2, Errors: 0 |
