| Bottom of 9: |
| Blue Jays ninth. Martinez in as catcher. Gimenez in as first baseman. Wells flied out to center fielder Sizemore. Rolen infield single to third. Overbay fouled out to third baseman Peralta. Rios grounded out, second baseman Carroll to first baseman Gimenez. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 1, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 9: |
| Indians ninth. Downs pitching. Garko pinch-hitting for Shoppach. Garko infield single to third. Valbuena pinch-running for Garko. Sizemore safe on fielder's choice and Overbay's error, Valbuena to third. Cabrera was intentionally walked. Choo grounded into fielder's choice, third baseman Rolen to catcher Barajas, Valbuena out, Sizemore to third, Cabrera to second. Martinez doubled to left, Sizemore scored, Cabrera scored, Choo to third. Hafner struck out. Peralta walked on a full count. Francisco grounded into fielder's choice, third baseman Rolen to second baseman Hill, Peralta out. |
| Runs: 2, Hits: 2, 1 Errors on Tor |
| Bottom of 8: |
| Blue Jays eighth. Barajas flied out to center fielder Sizemore. Bautista grounded out, second baseman Carroll to first baseman Martinez. Scutaro singled to center. Hill grounded into fielder's choice, third baseman Peralta to second baseman Carroll, Scutaro out. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 1, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 8: |
| Indians eighth. Accardo pitching. Peralta struck out. Francisco grounded out, second baseman Hill to first baseman Overbay. Carroll grounded out, third baseman Rolen to first baseman Overbay. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 7: |
| Blue Jays seventh. Wells flied out to center fielder Sizemore. Rolen homered to center on the first pitch. Overbay grounded out, pitcher Lee to second baseman Carroll to first baseman Martinez. Rios singled to left. Millar grounded into fielder's choice, third baseman Peralta to second baseman Carroll, Rios out. |
| Runs: 1, Hits: 2, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 7: |
| Indians seventh. Sizemore grounded out, shortstop Scutaro to first baseman Overbay. Cabrera popped out to right fielder Rios. Choo infield single to first. Martinez doubled to left, Choo to third. Hafner grounded out, second baseman Hill to first baseman Overbay. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 2, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 6: |
| Blue Jays sixth. Bautista fouled out to catcher Shoppach. Scutaro grounded out, shortstop Cabrera to first baseman Martinez. Hill lined out to right fielder Choo. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 6: |
| Indians sixth. Francisco lined out to center fielder Wells. Carroll struck out. Shoppach struck out. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 5: |
| Blue Jays fifth. Rios grounded out, pitcher Lee to first baseman Martinez. Millar fouled out to first baseman Martinez. Barajas struck out. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 5: |
| Indians fifth. Martinez flied out to right fielder Rios. Hafner lined out to third baseman Rolen. Peralta struck out. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 4: |
| Blue Jays fourth. Hill doubled to right. Wells struck out. Rolen flied out to center fielder Sizemore. Overbay grounded out, third baseman Peralta to first baseman Martinez. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 1, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 4: |
| Indians fourth. Carroll walked. Shoppach grounded out, first baseman Overbay unassisted, Carroll to second. Sizemore walked on a full count. Cabrera singled to left, Carroll to third, Sizemore to second. Choo grounded into a double play, shortstop Scutaro to second baseman Hill to first baseman Overbay, Cabrera out. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 1, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 3: |
| Blue Jays third. Millar doubled to left. Barajas grounded out, shortstop Cabrera to first baseman Martinez. Bautista fouled out to catcher Shoppach. Scutaro grounded out, second baseman Carroll to first baseman Martinez. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 1, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 3: |
| Indians third. Cabrera grounded out, shortstop Scutaro to first baseman Overbay. Choo singled to center. Martinez walked on a full count, Choo to second. Hafner struck out. Peralta walked on a full count, Choo to third, Martinez to second. Francisco struck out. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 1, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 2: |
| Blue Jays second. Rolen struck out. Overbay flied out to center fielder Sizemore. Rios grounded out, third baseman Peralta to first baseman Martinez. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 2: |
| Indians second. Peralta grounded out, shortstop Scutaro to first baseman Overbay. Francisco doubled to left. Carroll singled to center, Francisco to third. Shoppach struck out. Sizemore grounded out, third baseman Rolen to first baseman Overbay. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 2, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 1: |
| Blue Jays first. Scutaro struck out. Hill singled to right. Wells grounded into a double play, pitcher Lee to shortstop Cabrera to first baseman Martinez, Hill out. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 1, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 1: |
| Indians first. Sizemore struck out. Cabrera tripled to center. Choo struck out. Martinez was hit by a pitch. Hafner struck out. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 1, Errors: 0 |
