| Bottom of 9: |
| Blue Jays ninth. Wood pitching. Rios was hit by a pitch. Rios stole second. Bautista flied out to right fielder Choo. Barajas fouled out to first baseman Garko. Overbay pinch-hitting for McDonald.Rios stole third. Overbay struck out. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 9: |
| Indians ninth. Frasor pitching. Carroll grounded out, third baseman Bautista to first baseman Millar. Gimenez flied out to right fielder Rios. Sizemore singled to center. Cabrera grounded out, second baseman Hill to first baseman Millar. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 1, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 8: |
| Blue Jays eighth. Hill grounded out, second baseman Carroll to first baseman Garko. Lind struck out. Millar homered to left on a 2-0 count. Smith pitching. Wells grounded out, pitcher Smith to first baseman Garko. |
| Runs: 1, Hits: 1, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 8: |
| Indians eighth. Peralta singled to center. Garko struck out. Francisco grounded into a double play, second baseman Hill to shortstop McDonald to first baseman Millar, Peralta out. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 1, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 7: |
| Blue Jays seventh. Barajas grounded out, third baseman Peralta to first baseman Garko. McDonald infield single to short. Scutaro grounded into a double play, second baseman Carroll to shortstop Cabrera to first baseman Garko, McDonald out. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 1, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 7: |
| Indians seventh. Accardo pitching. Cabrera flied out to center fielder Wells. Choo grounded out, third baseman Bautista to first baseman Millar. Martinez grounded out, shortstop McDonald to first baseman Millar. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 6: |
| Blue Jays sixth. Millar grounded out, shortstop Cabrera to first baseman Garko. Wells doubled to right. Rios grounded out, pitcher Huff to first baseman Garko. Bautista flied out to right fielder Choo. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 1, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 6: |
| Indians sixth. Garko was hit by a pitch. Francisco singled to left, Garko to second. Carroll bunted into fielder's choice, first baseman Millar to third baseman Bautista, Garko out, Francisco to second. On Camp's error on a pickoff attempt, Francisco to third, Carroll to second. Gimenez grounded out, shortstop McDonald to first baseman Millar, Francisco scored, Carroll to third. Sizemore struck out. |
| Runs: 1, Hits: 1, 1 Errors on Tor |
| Bottom of 5: |
| Blue Jays fifth. Barajas struck out. McDonald popped out to shortstop Cabrera. Scutaro doubled to left. Hill homered to left on the first pitch, Scutaro scored. Lind struck out. |
| Runs: 2, Hits: 2, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 5: |
| Indians fifth. Gimenez singled to center. Sizemore flied out to left fielder Lind. Cabrera safe at second on Bautista's error, Gimenez to third. Choo tripled to left, Gimenez scored, Cabrera scored. Camp pitching. Martinez grounded out, second baseman Hill to first baseman Millar, Choo scored. Peralta struck out. |
| Runs: 3, Hits: 2, 1 Errors on Tor |
| Bottom of 4: |
| Blue Jays fourth. Lind doubled to center. Millar doubled to left, Lind scored. Wells popped out to second baseman Carroll. Rios struck out. Bautista popped out to second baseman Carroll. |
| Runs: 1, Hits: 2, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 4: |
| Indians fourth. Cabrera singled to center. Choo was hit by a pitch, Cabrera to second. Martinez walked on a full count, Cabrera to third, Choo to second. Peralta struck out. Garko struck out. Francisco walked, Cabrera scored, Choo to third, Martinez to second. Carroll struck out. |
| Runs: 1, Hits: 1, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 3: |
| Blue Jays third. McDonald grounded out, third baseman Peralta to first baseman Garko. Scutaro grounded out, second baseman Carroll to first baseman Garko. Hill fouled out to catcher Gimenez. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 3: |
| Indians third. Francisco flied out to right fielder Rios. Carroll walked. Gimenez struck out. Carroll stole second. Sizemore grounded out, first baseman Millar unassisted. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 2: |
| Blue Jays second. Wells grounded out, third baseman Peralta to first baseman Garko. Rios doubled to left. Rios stole third. Bautista grounded out, first baseman Garko unassisted. Barajas grounded out, third baseman Peralta to first baseman Garko. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 1, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 2: |
| Indians second. Martinez struck out. Peralta walked on a full count. Garko grounded into a double play, shortstop McDonald to second baseman Hill to first baseman Millar, Peralta out. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 1: |
| Blue Jays first. Scutaro lined out to center fielder Sizemore. Hill grounded out, second baseman Carroll to first baseman Garko. Lind walked on a full count. Millar grounded out, third baseman Peralta to first baseman Garko. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 1: |
| Indians first. Sizemore grounded out, second baseman Hill to first baseman Millar. Cabrera flied out to right fielder Rios. Choo struck out. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
