| Bottom of 9: |
| Blue Jays ninth. Encarnacion grounded out, second baseman Cano to first baseman Teixeira. Chavez singled to right. Bautista flied out to center fielder Cabrera. Scutaro singled to right, Chavez to third. Hill flied out to center fielder Cabrera. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 2, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 9: |
| Yankees ninth. Matsui homered to center on the first pitch. Posada fouled out to third baseman Encarnacion. Cano singled to right. Cabrera grounded out, second baseman Hill to first baseman Millar, Cano to second. Hairston Jr. flied out to left fielder Bautista. |
| Runs: 1, Hits: 2, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 8: |
| Blue Jays eighth. Hairston Jr. in as right fielder. Scutaro singled to left. Hill singled to left, Scutaro to second. Lind struck out. Millar struck out. Rivera pitching. Wells doubled to left, Scutaro scored, Hill scored. Rios grounded out, shortstop Jeter to first baseman Teixeira. |
| Runs: 2, Hits: 3, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 8: |
| Yankees eighth. Chavez in as catcher. Hinske flied out to right fielder Rios. Jeter grounded out, second baseman Hill to first baseman Millar. Damon homered to right on a 2-2 count. Teixeira homered to right on a 0-1 count. A.Rodriguez grounded out, shortstop Scutaro to first baseman Millar. |
| Runs: 2, Hits: 2, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 7: |
| Blue Jays seventh. Wells flied out to center fielder Cabrera. Rios struck out. Encarnacion doubled to right. Barajas walked on a full count. Hughes pitching. McDonald pinch-running for Barajas. Bautista struck out. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 1, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 7: |
| Yankees seventh. Posada singled to left. Cano grounded into a double play, second baseman Hill to shortstop Scutaro to first baseman Millar, Posada out. Cabrera grounded out, shortstop Scutaro to first baseman Millar. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 1, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 6: |
| Blue Jays sixth. Hill lined out to shortstop Jeter. Lind struck out. Millar grounded out, third baseman A.Rodriguez to first baseman Teixeira. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 6: |
| Yankees sixth. Teixeira grounded out, first baseman Millar unassisted. A.Rodriguez struck out. Matsui grounded out, first baseman Millar unassisted. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 5: |
| Blue Jays fifth. Barajas singled to right. Bautista grounded into a double play, first baseman Teixeira to shortstop Jeter to first baseman Teixeira, Barajas out. Scutaro lined out to third baseman A.Rodriguez. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 1, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 5: |
| Yankees fifth. Hinske struck out. Jeter grounded out, second baseman Hill to first baseman Millar. Damon grounded out, third baseman Encarnacion to first baseman Millar. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 4: |
| Blue Jays fourth. Hill singled to left. Lind struck out. Millar walked on a full count, Hill to second. Wells walked on four pitches, Hill to third, Millar to second. Rios hit a sacrifice fly to right fielder Hinske, Hill scored. Encarnacion grounded out, second baseman Cano to first baseman Teixeira. |
| Runs: 1, Hits: 1, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 4: |
| Yankees fourth. Posada popped out to left fielder Bautista. Cano grounded out, shortstop Scutaro to first baseman Millar. Cabrera flied out to center fielder Wells. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 3: |
| Blue Jays third. Barajas lined out to shortstop Jeter. Bautista walked. Scutaro lined into a double play, third baseman A.Rodriguez to first baseman Teixeira, Bautista out. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 3: |
| Yankees third. Jeter struck out. Damon grounded out, second baseman Hill to first baseman Millar. Teixeira doubled to left. A.Rodriguez infield single to third, Teixeira to third. Matsui flied out to center fielder Wells. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 2, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 2: |
| Blue Jays second. Wells struck out. Rios struck out. Encarnacion grounded out, first baseman Teixeira unassisted. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 0, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 2: |
| Yankees second. Cano singled to left. Cabrera grounded into a double play, pitcher Halladay to shortstop Scutaro to first baseman Millar, Cano out. Hinske lined out to first baseman Millar. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 1, Errors: 0 |
| Bottom of 1: |
| Blue Jays first. Scutaro grounded out, first baseman Teixeira unassisted. Hill grounded out, shortstop Jeter to first baseman Teixeira. Lind infield single to short. On Posada's passed ball, Lind to second. Millar struck out. |
| Runs: 0, Hits: 1, Errors: 0 |
| Top of 1: |
| Yankees first. Jeter struck out. Damon singled to left. Teixeira struck out. A.Rodriguez doubled to right, Damon scored. Matsui safe on Millar's error, A.Rodriguez scored. Posada flied out to center fielder Wells. |
| Runs: 2, Hits: 2, 1 Errors on Tor |
